Appendix N Challenge: Three Hearts and Three Lions by Poul Anderson.

So, this is the first book mentioned in Appendix N, but only because it’s put down in alphabetical order. I bought my copy through Amazon, paid a penny as well as 280 more for postage. It really is a wonderful world we live in isn’t it when we can get an idea, such as reading the books that inspired AD&D and can make it happen so easily.

I liked this book. I didn’t love it and I doubt that I’ll ever read it again, but reading it once was a little treat. It’s a fast read, my copy, a 1970’s reprint (with the above cover) has just 156 pages. Barely a novel by today’s often Brobdingnagian standards. Maybe the lesson they could though is that something happens every page, there’s no fat here, no pointless exposition, everything has both purpose and meaning. That in itself was enjoyable.

What wasn’t was the faux-Scots dialogue of some of the characters. It slowed down the pace, took you out of the story. But…it was a choice and I can see why the writer made it and I do wonder if readers back in the fifties would have had the same problem with it. Just about every book aimed at teaching writing tells you to avoid it and it’s certainly fallen out of favour in my lifetime.

Okay, you know the drill, spoilers ahead.

The story itself is a parallel worlds tale about a man taken from our world and deposited in another, one where he is a brave knight, complete with full armour, a beautiful horse and a serviceable weapon. There’s also a shield bearing the Three Hearts and Three Lions of the title. The rest of the tale is taken up with his quest to find out who he is, what he’s meant to do and how he is to get home. That and his relationship with the beautiful Swan-May who has fallen in love with him. We meet, wizards, elves, trolls and cannibals and witches and all have their part to play in his quest. As does a Muslim knight, the brave and true Carahue. It all happens so naturally that there are few points where you’re taken out of the story, which I guess is a testament to Mr Andersons’ skill as a storyteller.

Good and Bad have become Chaos and Law, which allows for a greater amount of nuance. Characters are driven by their adherence to either philosophy and act accordingly. Nowhere is this more clearly seen than in the character of Morgan Le Fey. (Can I just say that I prefer Morgana to Morgan? Morgan just sounds so…male! Damn you Morgan Freeman and your amazing acting!) Morgan shows on more than one occasion that she loves Carlson and does her best to protect him while advancing her own plans. Carlson has to fight the feelings that he has for her to do what he knows is right. It’s shades of grey done right and creates depth without leaving you feeling sullied by what you’ve read.

The story is as deep as you want it to be, I suspect you could build a career on ‘discovering’ the hidden messages within the book. As a final note I’d like to point out that although I was a little disappointed at how the tale ended, it felt like there were a hundred or so pages missing.  Saying that I’ve never felt so driven to write a fan-fiction sequel of my own before.

That’s all, for now, guys. Next will be The Face in the Frost by John Belliars.

Until then

Take care



4 thoughts on “Appendix N Challenge: Three Hearts and Three Lions by Poul Anderson.

  1. I think you would enjoy other Anderson fantasy novels like THE BROKEN SWORD, HROLF KRAKI’S SAGA and WAR OF THE GODS better than TH&TL. I know I did. That said, I reread “Three Hearts” every 10-15yrs or so.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I read a lot of Anderson’s sci-fi as a sprog, thanks to a well stocked school library. I’ll be looking out for the works you’ve highlighted while trawling local bookshops/charity shops, its always good to have a healthy TBR pile 🙂


    2. Poul is highly underappreciated as an SF author. I rank him as highly as any SF author out there, actually. My opinion of his SF work has been steadily climbing for the last 10-15yrs.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. His Time Patrol books really had a lasting impact on me, leading to a fascination with Time Travel that’s stuck with me. Which is a nice lead back to Merritt and The Ship. Bob Mayers’ Time Patrol books, though completely unrelated, have a similar feel. They’re not as good, but hells, Anderson won 7 Hugos when that was still a badge that guaranteed quality.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s